Personal tools

Skip to content. | Skip to navigation

Sections

Join the conversation on Linkedin  Follow us on Twitter  Watch LLDCN on Youtube  Like us on Facebook

 
You are here: Home Archive 2010 June 01 Opinion: Port Botany's tidal shift or temporary glitch?

Opinion: Port Botany's tidal shift or temporary glitch?

Posted by samc at Jun 01, 2010 11:00 AM |
Filed under:

Are we witnessing an historic tidal change at Port Botany? Long accused of prioritising the waterside operations of their Sydney terminals at the expense of landside efficiencies, both DP World and Patrick were battling to keep ships on schedule last week.

Opinion: Port Botany's tidal shift or temporary glitch?

A delicate balance: Resourcing at Port Botany a matter of interpretation (Photo: Sydney Ports)

__________________________________________

sam c serious small

sam.collyer@informa.com.au

Editor's Blog
__________________________________________

It is a situation that some shipping lines fear has developed as a byproduct of the New South Wales Government's landside policies.

Whether the lines are right appears to be a matter of interpretation.

Several ships were last week waiting for twice as long as they typically would, either at the berth or offshore.

Amazingly however, the congestion doesn't appear to have affected landside operations at either DP World or Patrick.

In fact, Patrick was still reporting 28 minute receival and delivery turnarounds last week despite other disruptions, including the unavailability of staff who were attending the funeral of a colleague.

At DP World, some of the ocean-side delays could be a product of its temporary restrictions on berths as part of work to commission the pair of post-panamax cranes that arrived two months ago.

The stevedore is also battling an increase in volumes stemming from its new-found majority share of the Sydney market.

As shipping lines braced for the possibility their vessels might miss windows at other ports, they have also quietly suggested that last week's situation could repeat itself.

In times of congestion, and without a regulatory stick hanging over their heads, the stevedores have long diverted resources to where they felt the most financial pain if they did not deliver.

Now the situation has changed.

Lines suggest the resources are being thrown back towards the landside operations at a time when both stevedores are eager to show the state government and Sydney Ports Corporation just how serious they are about voluntary performance improvement.

The horse may have already bolted.

Will NSW Government changes to Port Botany have long-term benefits for port efficiency? Should stevedores have to comply with the new regulated approach to landside performance if their operations are now performing well? Leave your comments below or email us at editorial@lldcn.com.au

Document Actions

Tidal Shift at Port Botany

Posted by Zalai at Jun 01, 2010 02:40 PM
It is essential that stevedores appropriately service the landside as well as meeting their shipping line KPIs for turnaround times of vessels.

To that end, the CBFCA welcomes the bold steps being taken by the NSW Government to provide fairness and equity into landside arrangements at the port, sharing the Government’s view that the PBLIS reforms will provide the necessary measures to help meet the challenges of projected activity at the port. Container trade at Port Botany reached a record high of 149,000 containers in March 2010. From July last year to March this year, it grew 4.8 per cent, compared to the corresponding period last year.

The CBFCA believe these performance standards, and associated penalties between stevedores and transport carriers, will greatly assist in easing landside congestion at Port Botany. Shipping lines and the stevedores, in particular, must appreciate that these measures provide definitive benchmarks that must be met if we are to gain greater efficiency across the entire supply chain.

We all must work in a spirit of co-operation if we are to lift productivity and meet the challenges of ever increasing demand at Port Botany.

Paul Zalai – CBFCA Manager Freight and Business Operations

Port Botany Landside Performance

Posted by Joseph at Jun 01, 2010 02:40 PM
Regulations are in place to keep us all accountable.

Why do most people stick to the 40km/h speed limit in school zones? Because there is a big stick with penalties attached if you don't obey the rules.

Same logic applies to Stevedore performance.

They are being closely looked at, so if ever they were going to perform, it would be now. There is no visibility into how many slots per hour get released, in any port around Australia. It's very difficult to secure a time slot in Brisbane regardless of lower volumes. This typifies that there is no accountability or visibility by Stevedores to anyone, other than their internal senior management.

Penalties have applied to Transport Companies for a decade & will continue to apply. For long term benefits to Port efficiency, the NSW Govt needs to regulate that total visibility of slots per hour is provided live & that Stevedores meet acceptable truck turnaround times - or else face penalties themselves for failing to obey the rules.

Port Botany Landside Performance

Posted by Banks at Jun 01, 2010 03:13 PM
Patrick has had TTT less than 40 minute for the almost six months. It is stupid to suggest that just because of regulation (introduced in May that doesn't start till end of this year) has changed behaviour.

We've had two men lose their lives and Caltex trying to gas us. Those kinds of things tend to affect productivity in any industry not just ours.

Proud Patrick

DPW & Patricks Port Botany

Posted by Anonymous User at Oct 20, 2010 01:38 PM
First thing is DP World & Patricks showing there operations are running well and not affected, yeah right!! There services are terrible. Trucks are still waiting all the way up to Simblist road. And on some occasions they are taking up to 4hrs to get a truck in the gates, loaded and out. DP World seems to be the worst one out of the two. Patricks do have some good days and then some bad. As for DP World everyday is a joke. Just ask the truck drivers and there operators.
When you call them to find out what's happening with timeslots, eldays, etc, they simply do not answer or never return phonecall messages left and on a number of times we have had the phone hang up in your face.
I don't know the answer but I do know one thing this problem has been going on for the 16years I have been in the industry and a lot longer than I have been in it.
I believe the answer is the shipping lines do not care what the importers or there carriers/logistics people have to go thru with dealing with such poor servicing from Botany wharfs. I think one option could be that the port authority with the shipping lines need to create a system together to equalise the workload at both ports as vessels arrive. This way the workload can be evenly distributed over both wharf and the wharfs need to start employing more permanent staff rosters to service there operations. Anyway enough said, one can only hope they will get it right before my time is over in this industry.

 







 

 
  • © Lloyd's List Daily Commercial News